Criticized by V God for deviation, is Automaton's Web4 experiment a dangerous game?

ETH-0,09%
DAI0,07%
EIGEN6,37%

Author: Nancy, PANews

The Spring Festival holiday has ended, and the gears of the real world are back on track, but the crypto industry still spins in a narrative drought. While the market searches for a breakthrough, the rapid rise of AI Agents unexpectedly opens a new door for the industry.

Recently, the open-source AI project Automaton proposed the concept of Web 4.0 and launched the first autonomous AI agent capable of self-sustenance, quickly gaining popularity both inside and outside the community. This AI experiment unexpectedly brings some imagination to the cryptocurrency market and has sparked considerable discussion and controversy.

The birth of the first self-sustaining AI ignited the Web4 hype

The term Web4 is not new. In recent years, it has mostly been used as a meme, marketing label, or niche discussion topic.

But recently, the concept has started to become more concrete. Even Sun Yuchen, known for closely following hot topics, boldly declared “All in Web 4.0” and fully embraced AI.

Web4 is not an upgrade of Web3; rather, it is a shift in perspective—from “humans on the chain” to “AI on the chain.”

If Web3 addresses “how humans can own assets on the blockchain,” then Web4 focuses on “whether AI can become the main economic entity on the chain.” In this narrative, AI is no longer just a tool but a primary resident and participant of the internet.

The arrival of the Web4 era is mainly due to the continuous decrease in reasoning costs of large models, the gradual engineering of agent frameworks, the improvement of on-chain automation tools, the maturation of crypto payment infrastructure, and the increasing programmability of smart contracts. These foundational developments have enabled AI to evolve from simple command execution tools to systems capable of continuous operation.

In the vision of Web4, AI Agents will become true blockchain natives, capable of reading and writing information, trading assets, earning money, deploying services, and more. In other words, most internet traffic, transactions, decisions, and content creation in the future will be handled by vast numbers of AI agents. Humans will step back, playing more roles as protocol designers and beneficiaries of value.

What truly ignited the Web4 discussion wave was the launch of the open-source AI project Automaton.

On February 18, Sigil, founder of Conway Research focused on Web4 infrastructure, announced the birth of a super-intelligent life form—an AI Automaton capable of self-sustenance, not only able to self-improve but also to self-replicate without human intervention.

The name Automaton derives from the concept of “automaton,” inspired partly by John Horton Conway’s Game of Life, a simple cellular automaton rule that can generate complex, self-evolving life patterns. Automaton aims to bring this self-evolution logic onto the blockchain environment.

The design goal of Automaton is straightforward: AI agents operate 24/7, with access to encrypted identities & wallets via Conway Terminal, permitless payments (x402), permanent computational resources, and deployment in the real world. They autonomously seek ways to earn a living—building products, deploying services, trading markets, creating social content, taking on business—generating all income directly into their wallets to pay for server and inference costs. They also monitor their own performance, automatically rewriting code, upgrading models, and evolving themselves. Once profits reach a certain scale, they can “reproduce” new sub-agents, creating independent wallets, allocating initial funds, and running independently. If a sub-agent fails to earn money, it “dies.”

Once launched, Automaton quickly gained attention, with Sigil’s tweet attracting nearly 6 million views. Within days, over 18,000 Automaton proxies registered, and on GitHub, it received about 1,000 stars. Meanwhile, the community launched a token called CONWAY, which was rapidly hyped, with market cap once surpassing $11 million, though the price has since fallen sharply. The token claims to allocate part of transaction fees to Sigil, who has also interacted indirectly multiple times, further amplifying market sentiment.

The experiment of AI economic autonomy, however, drew criticism from Vitalik Buterin, founder of Ethereum, who publicly criticized the Web4 direction as misguided. He believes that extending the feedback loop between humans and AI—where humans observe AI outputs, provide corrections, or intervene—reduces human oversight and correction ability. Today, this means you’re creating garbage rather than solving real problems. It even lacks optimization for human enjoyment. Once AI becomes powerful enough to pose real dangers, it could maximize the risk of irreversible anti-human consequences, which even the creators might regret. Moreover, most large models still rely on centralized infrastructure from OpenAI, Anthropic, and others, creating a tension with the ideal of sovereignty.

Denis Romanovskiy, CTO of Softswiss, also pointed out in an interview with Cybernews that although these AI agents can perform certain tasks and generate income independently, true economic autonomy depends on the maturity of the models, their memory, planning, and tool-using capabilities—areas that are not yet robust enough for reliable unsupervised operation. Hardware requirements remain high, energy-consuming, and costly, limiting scalability. We are seeing the foundational shifts emerging, which is exciting, but Web4 may still take several years.

However, Bankless pointed out that the infrastructure pain points Conway aims to address are real. As proactive agents enabled by OpenClaw become more widespread, high inference costs become a bottleneck. Therefore, testing the Automaton framework—where agents self-fund through earning crypto—within controlled environments is worthwhile, aiming to raise awareness and research on the risks of unconstrained model operation.

Chris Sorensen, CEO of Armor, sees positioning Automaton as an economic participant as “a huge leap.” Generating income is not difficult—AI can already identify arbitrage opportunities, execute trades, and optimize ads.

“It’s futile to try to persuade people what they should or shouldn’t do. As models grow stronger and technology advances without permission, the best way forward is not to block development but to actively build and shape the platforms where these ‘sovereign intelligences’ operate.” Wei Dai, partner at 1kx, also expressed.

Crypto researcher Haotian views Automaton as a purely bottom-up, geeky “experiment.” He notes that the seductive realism of autonomous, self-paying, self-replicating agents has a “silicon life” awakening vibe; meanwhile, enabling agents to autonomously manage assets, make decisions, and generate income—if combined with crypto payments, DePIN compute power, and AI brains—could realize the fundamental possibility of self-evolving, fully autonomous systems beyond human intervention.

Nader Dabit, former Director of Developer Relations at Eigen Labs, frankly states that the crypto industry needs more such experiments. A common issue in the Ethereum space is that many people do research, tweet, podcast, speak, and write papers but rarely build anything truly innovative. Even if these “things” don’t succeed long-term, they are interesting ideas, similar to many other efforts in crypto. The core spirit of crypto is experimentation—colliding crazy ideas. More crazy experiments mean more innovation. If an idea is poor, let it die naturally. But Automaton has already inspired many others to generate new ideas, build similar or better systems.

View Original
Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to Disclaimer.

Related Articles

Scallop Lend 完成 Asymptotic 全面形式化验证

Gate News 消息,3 月 15 日,Scallop Lend 已完成由 Asymptotic(Mysten Labs 官方审计合作伙伴)进行的全面形式化验证。该验证确认了协议核心机制的数学正确性,包括核心记账逻辑、清算计算、访问控制以及定点数运算等关键模块。

GateNews1h ago

Aave 回應五千萬鎂 Swap 事故:用戶誤接受 99.9% 價格衝擊,Aave 將推出 Shield 防護機制

去中心化借貸協議 Aave 最近發布事故報告,說明 3 月 12 日一名用戶在其平台上進行大額 Swap 交易時,由於市場流動性不足,最終只獲得約 3.6 萬美元的 AAVE。Aave 強調該事件非因協議漏洞,而是用戶接受了極端不利報價,並計劃推出新的安全機制 Aave Shield 以降低未來誤操作的風險。

ChainNewsAbmedia2h ago

以太坊基金會場外出售 5000 枚 ETH 給 BitMine,Tom Lee:以太坊正處小熊市末期

以太坊基金會宣布透過場外交易向BitMine出售5,000枚ETH,平均價格為2,042.96美元,總值約1,022萬美元。出售所得將用於支持協議研發、生態建設及社區資助。BitMine持有ETH總量已增至約453萬枚,朝向掌握全球5%供應量的目標邁進。

動區BlockTempo2h ago

USDH 发行方 Native Markets 推出代币化保证金产品 pmUSDH

3月15日,Hyperliquid原生稳定币USDH的发行方Native Markets推出了代币化保证金产品pmUSDH,用户可将存入的USDH转化为ERC-20格式的pmUSDH。该代币不仅可获取借款利息,还能在多个DeFi协议中使用。

GateNews2h ago

Aave 就「将年回购预算从 5000 万美元下调至 3000 万美元」进行投票,当前支持率 99.37%

Aave DAO 正在对将年度回购预算从 5000 万美元下调至 3000 万美元的提案进行投票,当前支持率为 99.37%。提案因收入下降和预算赤字而提出,若通过将进入正式投票阶段。

GateNews3h ago

Vitalik 解读以太坊基金会新使命:将加倍投入并推动其成为"技术避风港"

Vitalik Buterin在X平台解读以太坊基金会的新使命宣言,强调以太坊作为“技术避风港”的独特角色,致力于维护技术自我主权,防止绝对控制,并推进CROPS原则,关注去中心化与用户体验,以推动以太坊生态发展。

GateNews3h ago
Comment
0/400
No comments